Andy's Auto Rentals

Quick answer

Andy's Auto Rentals is a car rental agency situated at the Anguilla Ferry Terminal in Blowing Point Village 2640, Anguilla. The business has established a moderate reputation with a Google rating of 4.5 stars based on 130 customer reviews, though feedback appears to be polarized. The agency offers standard car rental services along with additional equipment rentals such as zero gravity chairs and umbrellas, catering to tourists and visitors arriving via the ferry terminal. While some customers report reasonable pricing and decent service, others have raised significant concerns about vehicle maintenance and customer service issues, particularly regarding the handling of mechanical problems and deposit disputes. The business appears to be operated by Andy and at least one other female staff member who handles check-in procedures. Reviewers frequently mention the contrast between Andy's perceived friendliness and the more business-like demeanor of the female staff member. The agency's location at the ferry terminal provides convenience for arriving passengers, though this advantage is somewhat undermined by reports of vehicles being delivered in poor condition, including cleanliness issues and apparent mechanical neglect. Despite these concerns, some customers indicate they would consider renting from Andy's Auto Rentals again, suggesting that their experience, while imperfect, met basic transportation needs for their Anguilla visit. GUEST EXPERIENCE: Customer experiences at Andy's Auto Rentals vary significantly, with recurring themes emerging from the review excerpts. Many guests appreciate the convenient location at the ferry terminal and find the rental rates reasonable for the island. Some customers particularly value the additional equipment available for rent, such as zero gravity chairs and umbrellas, which enhance their beach experience. The personal interaction with Andy is generally described positively, with multiple reviewers noting his pleasant demeanor and willingness to assist, though this contrasts with reports of the female check-in staff being strictly business-like without additional warmth or accommodation. Conversely, several customers have expressed serious concerns about vehicle quality and maintenance. Multiple reviews describe receiving cars that were visibly dirty, particularly with sand throughout the interior, and mechanically compromised. Specific complaints include non-functioning air conditioning systems, desperately needed shock absorbers, and tires with low tread that led to blowouts. The handling of these mechanical issues appears to be a particular point of contention, with at least one customer reporting that despite quick roadside assistance when a tire blew out, they were later blamed for the incident and charged accordingly. This inconsistent experience—where some find adequate service while others encounter significant problems—creates an unpredictable experience potential renters should consider.