Quick answer
Scilly Cay Restaurant is a distinctive dining establishment situated on a small private island in Anguilla, accessible only by boat, which adds to its exclusive and memorable experience. Located at address 2640, Anguilla, this restaurant has earned a solid 4.1-star rating from 45 Google reviews, reflecting a generally positive but occasionally mixed reception among visitors. The establishment is renowned for its stunning natural setting, featuring crystal-clear turquoise waters surrounding the island, which guests consistently praise as one of its most remarkable attributes. Scilly Cay offers an authentic Caribbean atmosphere that combines rustic charm with sophisticated dining, making it a notable destination for both tourists and locals seeking a unique culinary experience. The restaurant's menu appears to focus heavily on fresh seafood, with particular mention of lobster and beef skewers among the offerings. While some guests have expressed concerns about food consistency, noting occasional issues with seasoning such as overly salty portions, others have described the cuisine as "exquisite" and "very good." The establishment seems to position itself as a premium dining destination where guests are paying as much for the exceptional ambiance and unique location as for the food itself. This is evidenced by comments noting that "you're paying for the ambiance I guess," suggesting that the overall experience, including the journey to the island, is a significant part of the value proposition. GUEST EXPERIENCE: Guests at Scilly Cay Restaurant consistently highlight the extraordinary natural setting as the standout feature of their experience, with many describing the journey to the island as part of the adventure. The short boat ride across "crystal-clear turquoise water" to reach the restaurant is frequently mentioned as a memorable aspect that sets the venue apart from typical dining establishments. While the atmosphere is universally praised as "relaxed," "authentic," and "unforgettable," there appears to be some variation in how guests perceive the service quality, with some noting it as "friendly" while others found it to be slow, particularly during busy periods. The dining experience at Scilly Cay appears to be polarizing, with some guests having "wonderful" time praising the "exquisite" food and "very relaxing" ambience, while others left feeling underwhelmed given the price point. A common theme in reviews is the acknowledgment of "island time," with some guests expressing frustration at the slow service, including waiting over an hour for lobster and experiencing significant delays between server visits. Despite these service inconsistencies, many guests seem to appreciate the unique setting enough to forgive the pacing, with one reviewer noting they "survived lol beautiful setting!" The restaurant appears to be particularly well-suited for creating memorable experiences, with guests specifically mentioning it as "a nice place to take your family and a great place to make great memories."
In their own words
“Here’s a polished, enthusiastic review you could post: Scilly Cay is one of those places that reminds you why Anguilla is so special. From the short boat ride across the crystal-clear turquoise water to the moment you step onto this charming little island, the experience feels like discovering a hidden Caribbean paradise. The atmosphere is relaxed, authentic, and unforgettable. The fresh seafood—especially the famous grilled lobster—is absolutely delicious, the rum punch is a must-try, and the live music creates the perfect island vibe. But what truly makes Scilly Cay stand out is the incredible hospitality. The staff make you feel like family, and their warm, friendly service turns a great meal into an amazing experience. If you’re visiting Anguilla, Scilly Cay isn’t just a restaurant—it’s an adventure, a celebration of Caribbean culture, and a memory you’ll be talking about long after you leave. Five stars without hesitation. I can’t wait to return! Scilly Cay is known for its tiny private-island setting, fresh seafood, relaxed Caribbean atmosphere, and friendly service, all reached by a short boat ride from Island Harbour. It’s especially celebrated for its lobster lunches and laid-back island charm. Scilly Cay”
“Great location very stunning. Service was about average. For a space like that you expect better service. They forgot our drink order & some beef skewers room awhile to arrive come it tasted good. The first bit was very salty but the rest was good.. I’ve had better drink for much cheaper but you’re paying for the ambiance I guess. Overall solid experience but for the price you expect better food & service”
“Service sooo slow. I mean I get “island time” but an hour between visit from server was quite painful. Took over an hour between ordering lobster and actually getting it. And drink service also super slow. But we survived lol beautiful setting!”
“Had a wonderful time. Food was exquisite, staff friendly and ambience very relaxing. Its a nice place to take your family and a great place to make great memories”
Location
2640, Anguilla
Good to know
What type of business is Scilly Cay Restaurant?+
Scilly Cay Restaurant is listed as a restaurant in Anguilla.
Where is Scilly Cay Restaurant located?+
Scilly Cay Restaurant is located at 2640, Anguilla.
What is the guest rating of Scilly Cay Restaurant?+
Scilly Cay Restaurant has a rating of 4.1/5 from 45 Google reviews.
More places to eat
