Quick answer
The FishTrap is a well-regarded Caribbean restaurant located at 2640, Anguilla, boasting an impressive Google rating of 4.7 from 49 reviews. This establishment has garnered significant praise for its authentic Caribbean cuisine and particularly for its seafood offerings, which appear to be the restaurant's specialty. Despite occasional service challenges that some patrons have experienced, The FishTrap maintains a strong reputation for delivering delicious food and creating a pleasant dining experience that keeps customers returning. The restaurant seems to have a particular appeal to both locals and tourists, with mentions of live music events and a generally welcoming atmosphere that captures the essence of Caribbean dining culture. GUEST EXPERIENCE: Guests at The FishTrap consistently highlight the quality of the food as a standout feature, with particular praise for their seafood dishes such as the pot fish, parrot fish, and mahi fish tacos. While several reviews mention variable wait times for food - ranging from 40 minutes to over an hour - many patrons indicate that the quality of the cuisine makes the wait worthwhile. The restaurant's service receives mixed feedback, with some guests reporting exceptional service from specific staff members like Stephon and Sally, while others note occasional issues with slow service during busy periods or when the restaurant appears short-staffed. Despite these inconsistencies, the overall guest experience is generally positive, with many diners expressing appreciation for the friendly staff, relaxed atmosphere, and authentic Caribbean flavors that make The FishTrap a recommended dining destination in Anguilla.
In their own words
“There was no wait for a table and we were seated right away. It was an hour and 20 minute wait for the food to come out. There was only us and one other table when we arrived and put our order in. Once the food came, it was all right, but nothing spectacular. They had a live band with a lot of locals lingering in the parking lot watching. They were asking my husband for cash for a beer. Not our favorite spot.”
“We waited 40 minutes for a quesadilla and pasta, to go. We were the only ones in the restaurant. When I asked how much longer it would be they said 15 minutes. I asked to cancel and then they the brought the food out. Very strange, nobody ever explained why it was taking so long or talked to us.”
“We arrived a little after 6pm on a Tuesday. There was no wait for a table. Sally was our server and she was wonderful. We were a group of 6 and we ordered an assortment of drinks and food. The food takes a little while but it was worth the wait. We had a great time.”
“Pleasant staff, food took a little while but I believe it was a busy night lots of orders were coming out the kitchen after I ordered. But they made sure to update me during the wait. Food also tasted great. I got the pot fish(fried) with fries”
Location
2640, Anguilla
Good to know
What type of business is The FishTrap?+
The FishTrap is listed as a caribbean restaurant in Anguilla.
Where is The FishTrap located?+
The FishTrap is located at 2640, Anguilla.
What is the guest rating of The FishTrap?+
The FishTrap has a rating of 4.7/5 from 49 Google reviews.
More places to eat
